Details Emerge on Republican Alternative to DREAM Act

Details Emerge on Republican Alternative to DREAM Act


Before the tectonic plates shifted last week, there was a recent time that the Republican Party stood a chance to exploit the serious disaffection of the Latino and immigrant communities with the Obama administration.  Last spring, Senator Marco Rubio (R-FL) teased the electorate with a so-called “Republican DREAM Act.”  Although no legislation was drafted, Rubio’s attempt to reconcile his party with the immigrant community got serious attention.  Rubio’s proposal was described in the press as providing an opportunity for DREAMers to seek non-immigrant status.  His plan would have created a nonimmigrant visa for DREAMers, which would not generate a new pathway to residence, but would, rather, allow DREAMers temporary status and, if they could find a basis for residence through the traditional means, they would be allowed to adjust status to residence.  Of course, this is all hyperbole as none of this ever made it to the legislative drafting process because Rubio could not gather the support of his party.  The White House, however, was sufficiently concerned with the Rubio proposal that it asked DREAM advocates not to work with Rubio.  When DREAM advocates still seemed open to Rubio’s proposal, the White House moved on DACADACA took all the wind out of Rubio’s sails, and, as we have argued before, may have turned the tide for the President in this election.

Since the election exposed the GOP’s serious problem with the Latino and immigrant communities, Republicans have been moving fast towards greater receptivity to immigration reform as a salve to their self-inflicted wounds with Latinos.  On the heels of that stampede come details about Rubio reviving his alternate DREAM Act.  Yesterday, the Daily Caller reported details on the Republican alternative to the DREAM Act.   Additional details were provided by the National Review.  They are calling it the ACHIEVE Act and it basically follows the ideas that Rubio floated last spring.  According to the Daily Caller, the ACHIEVE Act would create a new nonimmigrant visa, dubbed the “W-1” that would allow a young person to attend college or serve in the military.  The details are a bit hazy, but it seems that the W-1 is to attend school or serve in the military.  The requirements for W-1 status are:

– Applicant must have lived in the U.S. for five years prior to the Act’s enactment

– Must have entered the country before age 14

– Must have good moral character

– Applicant must not have committed a felony, must not have committed more than one misdemeanor with a jail term of more than 30 days, must not have committed a crime of moral turpitude, and must not have a final order of removal pending

– Must have knowledge of the English language, U.S. history, and of principles of U.S. government

– Applicant must be 28 or younger at time of application (or 32 if they have a bachelor’s degree from a U.S. college);

– Must pay a $525 fee

– Must submit to a medical exam and a background check, submit biometric and biographic data, and register with the Selective Service.

According to the National Review, to maintain W-1 status, a student must: (1) check in with DHS every six months; (2) avoid welfare or government sponsored financial aid, and (3) maintain studies.  The National Review also says that W-1 students would also be able to work while attending school.

Upon completion of a degree, the student could seek a W-2 visa, which is a four year work visa.  An applicant must have received a degree or served four years in the military, continue to maintain the requirements of status regarding crimes, good moral character, welfare and reporting.  A $525 fee would also be required.  After completing four years of work, an applicant could then seek a W-3 visa, which would be renewable indefinitely every three years.  The program would provide no new means of seeking residence.  Residence may be sought through any of the existing means of seeking residence and, presumably, W-3s would be eligible for to apply for residence.

So, there you have it.  The first details of the Republican ideas regarding undocumented youth.  The eligibility requirements are considerably stricter and less generous than DACA and they impose tremendous work upon applicants and the immigration service.  In addition, the ACHIEVE Act would require undocumented youth to be in some form of temporary status for ten years before they could apply for a quasi permanent W-3 and/ or residence.

This proposal is a poor cousin to the DREAM Act.  Nonetheless, it ought to be welcomed as a departure from the “deport them all” and “self-deportation” rhetoric that has passed for policy in the GOP.  Republicans seem to have accepted the moral claim of DREAMers and have made a serious first offer as to a legislative solution.  It is far from perfect, but it represents miles in the journey that Republicans have traveled since last Tuesday.



Benach Collopy

Benach Collopy N/a
4530 Wisconsin Ave NW
Suite 400

DC 20016
Map & Directions