Remember the St. Louis

st. louis

Today, on Holocaust Remembrance Day, I am thinking about the M.S. St. Louis.  In 1939, while war waged in Europe, the M.S. St. Louis, a transatlantic ship carrying Jewish refugees fleeing the Third Reich, reached U.S. waters by way of Hamburg and Havana.  Seeking protection from persecution and a safe place to start over with their families, these refugees hoped to be admitted to the United States of America.  At the time, however, the Great Depression had fueled sentiments of xenophobia, nativism, and isolationism among U.S. citizens.  As a result, instead of welcoming “your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,” as inscribed on the Statue of Liberty, the U.S. turned the M.S. St. Louis back to Europe, where at least 254 of its refugee passengers were murdered in concentration camps.

The plight of refugees during World War II, such as those passengers on the M.S. St. Louis, had a profound impact on international and U.S. asylum policies, with the world declaring: “Everyone has the right to seek and to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution.” (See the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 14(1)).  The United States agreed that helping refugees was a moral imperative and has been engaging in refugee resettlement ever since the post-World War II era.  It seemed that the world had learned its lesson in morality, embracing freedom from persecution as a fundamental and inalienable human right.  But oh how soon we forget…

Today, invoking the same fear-fueled policies and xenophobic rhetoric that doomed the passengers of the M.S. St. Louis, Donald Trump signed an Executive Order suspending the U.S. refugee resettlement program for at least four months, and banning all refugees from being resettled in the United States – including people who are fleeing persecution, war, conflict, oppression, and human rights violations.

Here are some facts (actual facts, not “alternative facts”):

  • Refugees are people fleeing their homes in fear for their lives and the lives of their children.  More than half – 51 percent – of the world’s refugees are children.
  • Refugees do not get to choose the country in which they are resettled.  The United States handpicks the refugees who resettle here.
  • Vetting of refugees involves multiple layers of security checks involving the Department of Homeland Security, the FBI, the Department of Defense and intelligence agencies, making them the most thoroughly vetted group of people who come to the United States.
  • The refugee vetting process routinely takes 2-3 years to complete.
  • The refugee program wasn’t even suspended for this long after 9/11.  None of the 9/11 hijackers were refugees.

We are in the middle of the largest refugee crisis since World War II, and this Executive Order sends the wrong message to the world.  The Trump Administration’s willful disregard of our nation’s history and our moral obligation to provide meaningful protection to refugees is un-American and will only fuel anti-American sentiment worldwide.  Benach Collopy implores the Trump Administration to reverse course before the history books include the story of another M.S. St. Louis.

2 thoughts on “Remember the St. Louis

  1. In WWII, Jewish Refugees were not even remotely considered as possible terrorists. In hindsight is is clear that their ship was turned around due to the existance of big time antisemitism aimed specifically at the Jews as the purported killers of Jesus of Nazareth, a.k a., Jesús Christ, who was admitably a radical Rabbi who often opposed both Rome and the Sanhedrin.

    Trump, while not my candidate for President, is opposed to secret members of radical Islamic Groups, coming to America under the guise of political asylum for the express purpose of killing Americans. He is also opposed to those who would become easily radicalized, and respond to various radical tenants of Islam while here. In this regard neither Judaism nor Christianity are religions where SUBMISSION TO A CLERICAL ELITE who allegedly represent God are key tenants of faith.

    Thus unfortunately until we can know with some degree of clarity who is actually coming in, Trump feels a duty to existing American citizens to place their interest first. Will he be successful ? Only time will tell.

    1. That same fear mongering– the idea that the persecutors, the very people that the refugees were fleeing, would somehow sneak in with them and infiltrate our country– is not new. The rationalization you just provided for allowing thousands of people to die– the unfounded fear that some bad apples might get in– was also used to deny Jewish refugees entry because perhaps there were Nazi spies among them. History repeats itself when we don’t learn from our past mistakes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *